The Breakfast Club
Summary
John Hughes’The Breakfast Clubhas one of the most iconic endings in the history of teenaged comedies , but a possibility gives a twist to it and a grim meaning . In 1985 , John Hughes continued his reign in the humanity of teenaged comedy withThe Breakfast Club , a coming - of - age clowning - drama motion picture that go on to become one of the most influential movies of the tenner . The Breakfast Clubtook the audience to Shermer High School on a Saturday to follow five students in detention : Brian ( Anthony Michael Hall ) , Claire ( Molly Ringwald ) , Andrew ( Emilio Estevez ) , Allison ( Ally Sheedy ) , and John Bender ( Judd Nelson ) .
The group is overseen by principal Richard Vernon ( Paul Gleason ) , who warns them not to peach or move from their seats and to compose a 1000 - word essay on “ who you cerebrate you are ” . Despite their different personality , backgrounds , and school camp , the chemical group end up creating a firm chemical bond at the end of the daylight , andThe Breakfast Clubfamously ends with Bender walk through the school ’s football field , encounter his first in the airwave . AlthoughThe Breakfast Clubleaves piffling to conjecture , there ’s a colored hypothesis that completely changes the group ’s experience in detention and give way the ending a dark and complex twist .
star the " Brat Pack " , John Hughes ' high shoal classic The Breakfast Club also have an amazing soundtrack fill up with memorable air .
Breakfast Club Theory Says The Characters Are In Purgatory
The group wasn’t exactly in detention
It ’s not uncommon for moving picture and tv set show to get a “ they are all dead ” case of theory at some point , but in the case ofThe Breakfast Club , the approximation is weirdly meet . The theory ( viaUncle Mike ’s Musings ) suggest thatThe Breakfast Clubis a rip - off of Dante Alighieri’sThe Divine Comedy , but instead of change configurations to explore Dante ’s Hell , Purgatory , and Heaven , they all take place at school . grant to the author , detention embark on as Hell , with Vernon serve as the Devil , as he ’s the one bringing the characters in , giving them restrictions , and overseeing them , with the main role of making them have the worst prison term there .
As the characters start up opening up to each other and really getting to know each other , custody / Hell becomes Purgatory , including the moments where they had sport together , yet the Devil was still present . InThe Breakfast Club , the point of the graphic symbol opening up to each other and sharing their reasons for being in custody along with their fears is for them to create a unique bond , overcome their preconception and differences , and be able to volunteer Vernon an reply in their essay ( even if he does n’t wish it ) – according to the possibility , however , the head of it was to help oneself each other observe peace with their life and now their Death so they could move on to Heaven .
Atthe end ofThe Breakfast Club , the case found the peace of mind they ask , and when they left schooltime , they entered Heaven . Bender ’s triumphant clenched fist bump at the end , then , takes a darker and deeper meaning as it would be symbolizing his victory over Hell , Purgatory , and the Devil himself , as against all odds , he managed to hybridize over to Heaven with the assistance of his new friends .
Breakfast Club Theory Would Leave A Huge Plot Hole
This theory doesn’t solve the biggest question it raises
As credible as the theory is , it raises a huge question that it does n’t serve : if the characters ofThe Breakfast Clubdied before the events of the moving-picture show and they are now in Hell and Purgatory , how did they go ? The generator of the theory does n’t put up an account , but the eccentric ’s reason for being in detention might have the solution . While their intellect are mostly harmless , they could be train as uncomplete retentiveness , as they just receive to the afterlife and might still be processing their deaths .
With this in mind , Claire might have died when she skitter schoolhouse , Brian might have taken a real gas and killed himself , Andrew could have been killed by his father ( who he was afraid of ) , Allison could have finish in a bad place that led to her demise , and Bender might have been killed by his abusive father .
How This Theory Changes The Breakfast Club (& Makes It More Complex)
The Breakfast Club takes a darker yet deeper meaning
The chief reference ofThe Breakfast Clubbeing dead is a saturnine twist to this teen drollery , as they were all too young and did n’t deserve to decease , but it also make the movie more complex . Each role ’s struggles become a mountain deeper and more complex as they have to find out peace of mind with everything they did – being too vain and ego - centered , not survive up to expectations , succumb to peer air pressure , etc – so as to move on to nirvana . Given their different backgrounds and causes of expiry , the appendage is different for every character , but they all have the ability to help the rest find their peace . Bender ’s fist bump at the death ofThe Breakfast Clubmight even pinch at Bender being trapped in Hell and Purgatory for too long , and thanks to his young friends , he at long last made it out .
