Related
InLord of the Rings , Boromir ’s proposal of using one ring against Sauron was a regretful idea for various intellect . At the start ofLord of The Rings : The Fellowship of the Ring , the ring is add forth at the council of Elves , Men , and dwarf , organized by Lord Elrond , as they reunite to discuss what to do with the ring . As the discussion sparks among the player , various pick are considered , such as that brought forward by Boromir of handle the one ring against Sauron before deciding the halo is to be destroy in the fiery pits of Mordor .
InLord of the Rings , Boromir want to persuade the council to let him take the one ring to oppose Gondor as the realm is defending itself againstMordor , whose long - standing historyis roll in the hay to manyLord of the Ringsviewers . He conceive the one ring would have also helped Gondor to contend the malefic threat by using the one ring against Sauron . Ultimately , Boromir ’s plan could not have worked , as its established in this aspect when his proposal of marriage is dismissed , and the fellowship of the ring is shape , which Boromir becomes a part of .
Related : ring Of Power May Have on the QT Brought Back A Lost LOTR Movie Elf
The One Ring Would’ve Corrupted Whoever Used It
The main problem with Boromir ’s architectural plan is that the one ring would have of necessity corrupted whoever used it . As observable throughoutLord of The Rings : The Fellowship of the Ring , the ring confers sure powers to the toter of the band , such as extending the life of the mortal possessor and becoming much invisible to everyone but those able to perceive the non - physical public . However , the one closed chain also corrupted everyring bearer inLord of the Ringsto some storey , as it was endowed with malevolent energy because it contain so much of Sauron ’s power .
Therefore , whoever was going to wear upon the ring to aid Gondor against Sauron would have been corrupt by its evil power , peculiarly if it was not an gremlin , as hob are known to be less susceptible to putrescence in theLord of the Ringsuniverse . It is something that the audience sees with Bilbo and Frodo to some level since both Hobbits suffer the enticement of the ring . In fussy , the power of the one halo grow stronger on Frodo throughoutLord of the Ringsand , in exceptional , when he enter Mordor and approached Mount Doom to destruct it .
Sauron Would Survive Unless The Ring Was Destroyed
It is also important to notice that the ring needed to be destroyed to eventually defeatSauron in his eye form , which viewers see in theLord of the Ringsseries . This is because Gondor could not just use the one ring to shoot down Mordor , as Sauron would survive unless the ring were physically destroyed . This is why inThe Fellowship of the Ring , the council ultimately determine on the architectural plan the audience sees in the moving-picture show , which see Frodo bringing the one gang to Mordor in his quest throughout the movies . As such , Sauron is destroyed only at the last of theLord of the Ringstrilogy when Frodo destroys the ring .
Sauron ’s being is tied to that of the ring : as long as the ring survives , so does Sauron . He does n’t pop off when Isildor defeats him . Instead , he becomes the centre tie in with him inLord of the Ringsbecause theone mob still exist . In theLord of the Rings’mythology , Sauron is an immortal being , which means that his essence can not be easily destroyed . The latter is tied to the one ring itself as he had stream so much of his own might into it . This makes the end of the one ring essential to defeat Sauron .
relate : Every Extra Scene Added In Lord Of The Rings ' Extended Editions
Boromir Underestimated The Ring’s Will
Boromir ’s architectural plan was frightening because it did not consider the will of the one ring . InLord of the Rings , it is established that the tintinnabulation strove to return to Sauron by manipulate and grease one’s palms the ring - bearer . Therefore , while his effort to support his kingdom and expend any resourcefulness to do it may be admirable as it speaks to who Boromir is as a character , it is safe to say that Boromir underestimate the ring ’s own will , take over that it would allow anyone to apply it as they wish .
The hoop affects Boromir at theend ofFellowship of the Ring , as he sway away from his hope to Frodo for the malign influence of the one band . The same could have happened if Boromir had take the ring to defend his people , as the one anchor ring corrupt its pallbearer regardless of their good intentions . Moreover , as luff out by Aragorn inFellowship of the Ring , Boromir would not have been able-bodied to manage the ring as he did not know how to use it . finally , the plan ordain inLord of the Ringsis probably the only one that would actually figure out .
More : Why Tolkien Canon Is So light To Break In Rings Of Power ( & In General )
