Summary

Warning : contain SPOILERS for Star Wars : Darth Maul - Black , White & Red # 1!Emperor Palpatinehas a reputation for being one of the greatest Sith Lords inStar Warshistory , as he single - handedly did what the intact Sith Empire miscarry to do thousands of years earlier : eradicate the Jedi and conquer the Galactic Republic . However , unlike the Sith of old , Palpatine seems to have a total disregard for Sith school of thought , and only follow certain aspects of the dark faith that suit his need . And now , Palpatine is confirming his emplacement as a Sith hereticas he assay to harness ‘ the Netherworld of the Force ’ .

In a trailer forStar Wars : Darth Maul - Black , White & Red#1 by Benjamin Percy and Stefano Raffaele , Darth Sidious is sendingDarth Maul on a charge to capture members of a dark side furore call in the Final Occultation , who are being transported on a prison house ship . This story takes place before the consequence of The Phantom Menace , meaning Palpatine is still trying to increase his strength in the dark side any manner he can - including learning the secrets of the Final Occultation .

As detailed by Darth Maul in the preview , the Final Occultation is “ aided by chaotic strength from the Netherworld ” , indicating that their connection to the dark side of the Force is different from that of the Sith , and is perhaps more in - railway line with the Nightsisters of Dathomir , give the more mysterious undercurrent of ‘ helter-skelter forces from the Netherworld ’ . In any case , the Final Occultation knows how to access dark power Palpatine does not , and Darth Sidious hop to remediate that as quickly as potential .

Star Wars' Luke Skywalker, Darth Vader, and Emperor Palpatine.

Breaking Sith doctrine to study other forms of dark side power is something that Palpatine does n’t even think twice about doing , examine that he is a false Sith .

Why Darth Maul’s Latest Star Wars Mission Makes Palpatine a False Sith

One of the major selling point of accept the dark side as a Force - wielder is total freedom from the rig structure and seemingly absurd rules of the light side - wield Jedi . A dark sider can tip into their raw emotion , they can be with whoever they want , and they can fairly much do whatever they want . One great example of the true nomadic freedom of accept the dark side can be found with the dark side cult , the Knights of Ren , who are effectively traveling barbarians who take whatever they want anywhere they go .

The Knights of Ren ultimately led to the last corruption of Ben Solo , who became their leader upon killing their original ‘ Ren ’ , and taking up the name Kylo Ren . Interestingly , this avenue of dark side depravation meant Kylo Ren was n’t a Sith during theStar Warssequel trilogy , despite on the Q.T. being the apprentice of Emperor Palpatine the whole clip .

So , if the dark side offers ultimate exemption with the hope of untold mightiness , why ca n’t Palpatine study any dark side technique he wants ? Well , that ’s just it : ‘ Sith ’ and ‘ dark side ’ are not necessarily synonymous .

Far Side, cowboys with hands in the air (foreground) Union soldier giving general

The Sith exclusively use the sinister side of the Force , but using the dark side of the Force does n’t mechanically make one Sith . The Sith , like the Jedi , is an ancient religious belief with strict doctrine , and while Palpatine follow enough of the Sith ’s path to technically be one , he also does n’t take care flex the rules a morsel for the rice beer of index . Attempting to get to the Netherworld of the Force would be a rejection of Sith doctrine for the saki of harness the chaos of the Final Occultation - and it would n’t be Palpatine ’s first time venturing into moody side magicks .

Darth Sidious Learned Dark Side Magick from Mother Talzin, Further Proving His Flipancy with Sith Doctrine

Star Wars: Darth Maul - Son of Dathomirby Jeremy Barlow and Juan Frigeri

The miniseriesStar Wars : Darth Maul - Son of Dathomirconfirms that Mother Talzin ( the drawing card of the Nightsisters ) taught Palpatine certain spells and rituals using dark side magick . In fact , it turn out that they even made plans to rule the wandflower together , as Palpatine also offered Talzin certain knowledge of the disconsolate side that only the Sith know . It was a partnership , though one that was fated to end in betrayal and bloodshed , as Palpatine could never share the pot with another unless he was still in full controller .

In the end , Mother Talzin was defeated by Palpatine , which allowed Darth Sidious to bear on on his dark seeking to conquer the entire galaxy as the Emperor . Though not before Palpatine learned everything he could from her , which gave him a deeper savvy of the more mystical aspects of the dark side that would n’t have been possible to determine from the Sith alone .

While it bestow to Palpatine ’s overall power - grade as a dark side wielder , pick up Nightsister magick made him a less committed Sith Lord , which is the same situation he ’s in now with the Final Occultation .

peanuts' charlie brown and snoopy

Palpatine’s Technological Perversions are the Real Reason He’s a Sith Heretic

Darth Vader#6 (2015) by Kieron Gillen and Salvador Larroca

Like Darth Maul , who is now questioning Darth Sidious ’ commitment to the Sith ways in the Black , White & Red preview , Darth Vader once called the Emperor a Sith misbeliever when he found out that Palpatine was build a strike - squad of lightsaber - handle bionic man . However , Palpatine silence Vader by say that he was just as much of an abomination as these other bionic man , as Vader was more auto than military personnel . While Palpatine ’s point in time did cease Darth Vader ’s criticism , it did n’t confute Vader ’s claim that Sidious was a heretic - in fact , it only strengthened it .

Emperor Palpatine on a regular basis mix dark side energy with technology , and Vader himself is a shining example of that Sith heresy . While using technology to put back a lost limb , or something of that nature , is totally all right , Darth Vader ’s case is a spot more extreme , as he would be all in if not for the tech keeping him live . For a Sith , that would mean that he ’s too weak to continue , and if Palpatine was a ‘ honest Sith ’ , then he would have left Vader to conk on Mustafar follow his frustration to Obi - Wan Kenobi .

Palpatine used applied science to bring Darth Vader back from the brink of decease , making Darth Vader a surviving example of Palpatine ’s Sith heresy - and Vader ( nor the other cyborgs Palpatine trained ) is n’t the only one .

Star Wars' Emperor Palpatine with a dark side cult behind him.

Palpatine’s Resurrection & Project Necromancer are the Greatest Examples of His Sith Heresy

Star Wars: Episode IX - The Rise of Skywalker

While Darth Vader may have called Palpatine out for practices that any truthful Sith would consider heresy ( despite fundamentally being one himself ) , the most heretical thing Palaptine has ever done was restoration to spirit , as revealed in The Rise of Skywalker . To be clean , wander demise is not newfangled for a Sith , with Darth Sion being perhaps the great exemplar of a Sith Lord who gained immortality through sheer will and great power alone . However , it is the way of life Palpatine pass about cuckold death that makes him a heretic .

Darth Sion used the morose side of the Force to halt his decompose torso together long after he should have pass . Palpatine , on the other hired hand , used technological advancements like cloning and ripe lifespan support systems that were infuse with dark side DOE ( and perhaps Nightsister magick ) to pull off the same effort . Both Sith chisel death , but one did so as a lawful adherent of the Sith , while the other used any agency he could , including alternative boulevard in the dark side and ( most unforgivable of all ) technology .

Darth Vader was responsible for for killing a great number of Jedi , though ironically , he was also responsible for ensuring their survival in Star Wars .

Emperor Palpatine surging with Force-lightning.

The senator for Naboo, Palpatine rose to power and influence during the dying days of the Republic. In reality, his public persona was just a mask; he was really Darth Sidious, greatest of the Sith Lords, and he used his political skills and Machiavellian cunning to bring down both the Republic and the Jedi. Palpatine ruled his Galactic Empire for decades, until he was betrayed by his apprentice, Darth Vader. Even this wasn’t enough to stop the Emperor, however, as he was resurrected by his followers - only to be defeated once again.

Darth Sidious would n’t venture into full - scale Sith heresy until after he became Emperor ( at least , as far as Star Wars rooter have been made aware ) , though his action meddling in alternative avenues of great power in the dark side that disregard Sith doctrine have been taking stead even since before the prequel trilogy . And now , devotee have been made cognizant of one more , asEmperor Palpatineattempts to rein in ‘ the Netherworld of the Force ’ inStar war : Darth Maul - Black , White & Red , which only further prove the idea that he is a false Sith inStar Wars .

Star war : Darth Maul - Black , White & Red # 1by Marvel Comics is available April 24 , 2024 .

Star Wars : Darth Maul - Black , White & Red#1 ( 2024 )

Palpatine fighting Mother Talzin and Darth Maul at once.

generator : Octo Beard / YouTube

The senator for Naboo , Palpatine get up to power and influence during the dying days of the Republic . In reality , his public persona was just a mask ; he was really Darth Sidious , greatest of the Sith Lords , and he used his political skills and Machiavellian cunning to bring down both the Republic and the Jedi . Palpatine rule his Galactic Empire for decades , until he was snitch by his apprentice , Darth Vader . Even this was n’t enough to stop the Emperor , however , as he was revive by his follower - only to be kill once again .

Darth Vader calling Palpatine a Sith heretic to his face.

Cover of Star Wars: Darth Maul - Black, White & Red featuring Darth Maul.

Ian McDiarmid as Emperor Palpatine in Star Wars Return of the Jedi

The senator for Naboo, Palpatine rose to power and influence during the dying days of the Republic. In reality, his public persona was just a mask; he was really Darth Sidious, greatest of the Sith Lords, and he used his political skills and Machiavellian cunning to bring down both the Republic and the Jedi. Palpatine ruled his Galactic Empire for decades, until he was betrayed by his apprentice, Darth Vader. Even this wasn’t enough to stop the Emperor, however, as he was resurrected by his followers - only to be defeated once again.

Emperor Palpatine/Darth Sidious

Star Wars