Related
An unlikely object is at the center of aHow I Met Your Motherplot mess : Marshall and Lily ’s toothbrush . Having been together since college , Marshall and Lily are the most satisfying couple onHow I Met Your female parent . With such a long romantic history , Marshall and Lily are bind to be incredibly tightlipped and share more than just secrets .
Though Lily and Marshall stop up when she swallow an nontextual matter fellowship across the country andLily vanish briefly inHIMYMseason 4 , Marshall and Lily are closing goals . Marshall and Lily have crusade for their kinship and to good themselves . However , their john habits are confutable as Marshall and Lily ’s soup-strainer creates an unexpectedHIMYMplot hole .
How I Met Your Mother’s Toothbrush Story Makes No Sense
InHow I Met Your Motherseason 1 episode “ Zip , Zip , Zip , ” Marshall and Lily are come across in the toilet , brush their teeth at the same time , proving the soup-strainer story insert afterwards makes no good sense . InHow I Met Your Motherseason 5 episode “ Perfect Week , ” Marshall and Lily unveil how they have been sharing a soup-strainer for years . It is revealed that while go with Ted , the three shared the same toothbrush as Ted thought they kept their soup-strainer in the bedroom .
Marshall and Lily think a shared toothbrush is entirely normal , whereas everyone around them intend it ’s strange . They even pall off a novel couple when they accidentally mention “ our toothbrush . ” However , after the reveal about using Ted ’s soup-strainer , Marshall and Lily come out visually disgusted , potentially implying that they each think the lone toothbrush belong to the other and not Ted . The shared soup-strainer uncover straight contradicts their late bathroom behavior .
Explaining Marshall & Lily’s HIMYM Toothbrush Plot Hole
How I Met Your female parent ’s share toothbrush floor may have a completely reasonable explanation . regard the theory thatTed ’s narration made Barney wait badintentionally , it ’s entirely possible that Ted ’s narration would purposely misdirect his kid into intend Marshall and Lily had separate toothbrushes , so he could tell the real story later . It would make sense because , at that point in the story of issue , Ted has no clue Marshall and Lily are sharing a soup-strainer .
It ’s also years later that Ted is telling the story . So it would no longer be surprising that Marshall and Lily share a soup-strainer . If he mention the duo was brush their teeth during his story , his kid will naturally feign it is with disjoined toothbrush and not use up turns . How I Met Your Motherdoes not give a solid reason behind the toothbrush secret plan hole , but Marshall and Lily ’s shared toothbrush is a strange use that ingeminate their cheeseparing relationship .
