You
Warning ! This article hold back coddler for You time of year 4 part 1 , and potentially You time of year 4 part 2 !
As an underwhelming follow - up toYou ’s season 3 finale , the Netflix show ’s fourth season brings its stalker / in series killer , Penn Badgley ’s Joe Goldberg , to the heart of the London elite and a murder whodunit . But alternatively of Joe being the perpetrator , he ’s evidently take aim on a protective role towards gallerist and guilty rich Kate Galvin ( Charlotte Ritchie ) who he believes will be the next dupe . With the rich dropping like rainfly , Joe races to unveil the Eat the Rich slayer ’s identity before he stamp out anyone else and pins it on Joe .
InYouseason 4 , episode 5 , Rhys Montrose ( Ed Speelers ) , an aspiring mayoral candidate and part of London ’s rich clique , at last reveals himself to Joe as the Eat the fat sea wolf . As teased inYouseason 4 part 2 ’s trailer , Rhys desire a ally who share his pathologic interest in execution and conceive to have happen that in Joe . However , Youseason 4 part 1 does n’t seem as it appears as many point do n’t add up . So of course , suspicious audience across the internet have crazily put forth a hypothesis .
come to : Is Love Alive ? ! You Season 4 Part 2 ’s Trailer Tease Explained
You Theory: Rhys’ Eat The Rich Killer Persona Is Curated By Joe’s Imagination
Although Rhys Montrose is a real person inYouseason 4 , he is n’t the cause of death that Joe and his explicit admittance make him up to be . arrive at traction on several different word forums , thisYouseason 4 theory basically points out thatRhys ’ rust the Rich killer personais a mere production of Joe ’s imagination . Seeing as Joe has a story of conjuring up things that do n’t exist , Netflix ’s nonmigratory prowler envision his perverse penchant for violence onto another person ( one that ’s hallucinatory for that thing ) is n’t that far - fetched . Plus , there ’s evidence to patronage this hypothesis .
For starters , all of Joe and Rhys ’ interaction inYouseason 4 , part 1 has not been participated by any appendage of the London grouping . And if they are within the vicinity by prospect , no one ever recognize Rhys ’ mien . Even during the dining scene inYouseason 4 , episode 2 , Joe responds “ I ’m hunky-dory ” to Rhys ’ comment of him being sick , but somehow , everyone else appears to have only heard Joe mumble . Moreover , Rhys is an outlier of the Sundry House people . Despite being insanely plenteous like the rest period of them , Rhys partake in a similar abusive background signal asYou ’s Joe Goldberg ; which is probably the reason why Joe identify with Rhys .
Another thing to consider is that Joe ’s intact knowledge of Rhys add up from his own autobiography give to him by his educatee Nadia , play by Amy - Leigh Hickman . So there ’s that sense of intimacy Joe probably feel with Rhys , as opposed to the others who Joe only ever knows about from digging through their socials . to boot , Joe ’s stalker who texts him using an app that makes messages vanish after reading them is also a tell - tale sign that Rhys ’ homicidal side is all in Joe ’s head .
Why Joe Goldberg Is Still You’s Bad Guy
At the end ofYouseason 3 , Joe is visibly shaken at his newfound ego - sentience confirming that he is n’t a good person . With his guilt at being the instrument to other people ’s gruesome death rising to the cutting edge of his awareness , Joe is determined to turn a new leaf and become a in effect someone inYouseason 4 . However , Joe want to exchange does n’t mechanically mean that the unhinged part of his brain switches off on command .
relate : You Season 4 Confirms It ’s Time For The Show To EndNetflix’sYouhasn’t outright diagnose Joe Goldberg with any upset or mental sickness , but it ’s quite obvious that he is n’t of sound mental electrical capacity . interview even suggest that Joe has two personalities in one body - one who ghost over fair sex and care violence , and the other who just wishes to be normal - something that Beck ’s healer mentions Dr. Nicky back inYouseason 1 . In some instance inYouseason 2 and 3 , Joe ’s internal soliloquy - ing gets so bad that he hallucinate there being two of him arguing about his very nature .
Youseason 4 is suspiciously doing the same thing , only this time , Joe is using a curated version of Rhys as a disassociated constituent absolving him of his guilty conscience . Moreover , You ’s integral premise is Joe being the villain . So it does n’t really make good sense for Netflix’sYouto change that , especially consider that the murders have all been a tad too commodious for his position .
You Season 4 Changing Its Villain Doesn’t Make Sense
There being a second coming of Victoria Pedretti ’s Love Quinn via Rhys Montrose ’s character is awfully extra forYou , a show that tries to outdo itself every season . Of course , considering that Rhys , as the Eat the Rich killer , does n’t have the motif to defeat Malcolm , Simon or even Gemma , he was also nowhere near any of those murders . But coincidently , Joe Goldberg was , despite claiming that he remembers nothing . handily blacked out every time someone die , it ’s potential that Joe ’s Rhys projection commits theYouseason 4 part 1 murdersduring the times he claims he pass out .
InYouseason 4 , episode 1 , Joe was intoxicated and high when Malcolm was murdered in his apartment . InYouseason 4 , instalment 2 , Joe fell asleep on a workbench outside the gallery where Simon was mutilate . And inYouseason 4 , instalment 4 , Roald agitate Joe out of a high window ( obviously , passing out ) before Gemma was found drained in Kate ’s room . Given the facts , Youseason 4 may be throw audiences off with its Rhys character but still staying true to its heart narrative of Joe being its scoundrel because anything otherwise does n’t really add up .
Related : Why You Season 4 ’s Eat The Rich Killer Broke Their Signature Trend
Why It’s Best That Joe Is Still The Main Villain In You
Netflix’sYoushouldn’t roll away from its main concept of Joe Goldberg being the unsound guy cable . After everything he has done , the last thing thatYou ’s showrunners should be doing is giving Joe a hand out of a redemption electric arc ( by thwarting another killer whale ) which he distinctly does n’t deserve . As a stalker / serial killer , Joe atone for his felonies and live out his guilt is the least he could do without being caught and punish by the legal philosophy . Moreover , You ’s appeal stems from a captivation with Joe ’s perverted rationality of his darkness .
Netflix ’s calculated two - part press release ofYouseason 4 raises some eyebrows as it teases underlying plot equipment . However , asYouhas yet to affirm Joe Goldberg ’s translation from a hunter to a protector , the upcomingYouseason 4 part 2leaves much to be uncovered . And keeping in idea Nadia ’s description of “ whodunit ” novels , Youas a murder enigma is n’t exempt from there being no coincidences .
More : Why It ’s Good Jenna Ortega ’s Ellie Did n’t Return In You time of year 4
