Stranger Things
The Duffer Brothers shot down a Jonathan and Hopper father - son storyline that would have ruinedStranger thing . David Harbour recently shared aStranger Thingstheory that he and Winona Ryder came up with for their characters Hopper and Joyce Byers . Harbour and Ryder wanted to create a backstory that Hopper was Jonathan ’s male parent because the two had a one - night stand while Joyce and her ex - married man Lonnie had break up for a while . They got back together shortly after , and Joyce never severalize him about the nighttime with Hopper , so he always thought Jonathan was his Logos . The Duffer Brothers hated the approximation .
Lonnie was a recurring lineament throughoutStranger Thingsseason 1 who mistreated Joyce and his two sons . He was negligent , and it ’s suggested he was scurrilous toward Joyce . His inability to the right way bonk and care for his sons stimulate Jonathan to step up and be a father figure to Will . While it would have been skillful to see Jonathan have a loving founder like Hopper , the storyline Harbour and Ryder come up with in reality make Hopper seem like a worse person , does n’t move the patch frontwards in any way , and would ’ve created a immense mass for the show creators to try and clean up .
have-to doe with : Why Murray Is A secure catch For Joyce Than Hopper In Stranger Things
Hopper Being Jonathan’s Dad Adds Nothing To Stranger Things
Stranger Thingshas had a lot of mysteriesto tackle in the seven years it ’s been airing on Netflix , and the Hopper Jonathan storyline would have added nothing to the show . A series likeStranger Thingsdoesn’t have time for b plot that do n’t move the story forward . The focus of the series is on the characters shoot down The Hawkins Lab and the many villain coming from The Upside Down .
There have been a few side romance plots , like Hopper and Joyce , but these have go well with the main narrative . Hopper and Joyce being together demonstrate how much they ’ve bonded and develop together through scrap against The Upside Down brute and saving Will .
Hopper being Will ’s father , has no connection to the show ’s main role and would seem like a random storyline thrown in just to cause controversy . Jonathan has enough to deal with , being a beginner form to his chum , cop with where he and Nancy stand , and presently seek to defeat Vecna . In addition , learning Hopper is his father would add more stress for Jonathan .
Stranger Things' Hopper Secret Would Have Raised Needless Questions
Stranger Thingswould be liquidate a lot of time answering questions that could have been fend off without the idiotic storyline . The storyline would have created a lot of game holes , and rooter would desire answer about how the affair materialise , why it never came up before , and if Hopper was aware he was the begetter .
Related : Stranger Things Season 4 ’s Plot Holes & Headscratchers
If he knew , then why did n’t he say anything preferably ? It would make many problem in the dynamic between Jonathan , Will , and Joyce , realise her look like a bad mother for consist to her boy his entire life . The show could also make fans find bad for Lonnie , which is n’t utile , considering he was n’t a good somebody and is n’t even relevant to the floor anymore .
Hopper’s Jonathan Connection Would Ruin His Story With Eleven
What initially madeStranger Thingsfans fall in erotic love with Hopper is his connection with Eleven . The serial enclose Hopper on the show as a grumpy sheriff , but his backstory of losing his daughter to genus Cancer helped fans sympathize with him . Hopper was get by with a deal of heartache from his girl ’s death , and taking on the father role for Eleven was healing for him . So whenHopper find Eleven inStranger Thingsseason 1after she on the face of it died and hid her in his house to protect her , it began one of the show ’s most beautiful relationship .
Unfortunately , this all could have been ruined if he were Jonathan ’s founder . The plot line would mean Hopper spent years not being a Church Father to Jonathan . When he was mourning his girl , he had another child with whom he could have bonded , but instead , he ’d abandoned him . Even if he did n’t recognize Jonathan was his Logos because Joyce never told him , he likely would have had suspiciousness but never acted on them .
This messes with the reasonHopper’sStranger Thingsrelationship with Eleven is so herculean . She occupy the hole his girl left , but Jonathan could have filled this hole years ago . It ’s good for actors to bang their character so well that they feel cheer to originate storylines for them , but the Duffer Brothers were right to tell Harbour that hisStranger Thingsbackstory was " terrible . "
