Related
Summary
TheHarry Pottermovies bring the magic of the books to animation , but this also highlighted some of the novels ’ problems , inconsistencies , and plot hollow , such as one about the Portkey inHarry Potter and the Goblet of Fire – and now a dark theory solves this plot hole but nominate the movie even lamentable . ThroughouttheHarry Pottersaga , watcher learn a flock about the Wizarding World , its culture , and its many enchantment and spells , and the adept and witches have some peculiar direction of transporting themselves .
The audience saw Harry Potter ( Daniel Radcliffe ) and company using trains , fly railway car , charming jitney like the Knight Bus , and even fireplaces thanks to the Floo internet . InHarry Potter and the Goblet of Fire , a unlike transportation method in the Wizarding World was introduce : Portkeys . These were used by the Weasleys , Harry , Hermione , Cedric Diggory ( Robert Pattinson ) , and his father Amos Diggory to move around to the Quidditch World Cup , and it was Harry ’s first experience with a Portkey . Another Portkey evince up in the last deed of the movie as a way to take Harry to Voldemort , and Harry used it to fall to Hogwarts with Cedric ’s idle body – and this create a plot of ground kettle of fish that a dour theory has now solve .
Harry Potter Theory Explains Why Harry Was Able To Bring Cedric Back To Hogwarts
Cedric’s death allowed Harry to bring him back
As mentioned above , the first Portkey seen in theHarry Pottersaga was an honest-to-goodness boot that the Weasleys , Harry , Hermione , and the Diggorys used to get to the Quidditch World Cup . A Portkey was used again in the final third of the movie , though it was an unknown one . For the third chore during the Triwizard Tournament , the Champions had to go through a tangle to reach the Triwizard Cup , site at the nerve center . Harry and Cedric found the Cup at the same time and agreed to take it at the same fourth dimension in ordination to be key the winners , but unbeknownst to them ( and everyone else , really ) , the Cup was a Portkey created by Barty Crouch Jr. ( disguised as Alastor Moody ) . So , when Harry and Cedric meet the Cup , they were send to a graveyard where Voldemort was revive .
Unfortunately , when Peter Pettigrew and Voldemort see that Harry was n’t channelize alone and Cedric seek to defend himself and Harry , Voldemort ordered Peter to kill Cedric . Voldemort needed Harry ’s blood to to the full resurrect , which is why he set the Portkey up with Barty Crouch Jr. ’s help , and once he got his trunk back , he challenged Harry to a affaire d’honneur . With the aid of his parent ’s ghost and that of Cedric , Harry was able-bodied to distract Voldemort long enough for him totake Cedric ’s trunk and Accio the Cupso he could riposte to Hogwarts .
The plot of land hollow is thatHarry Potterestablished that , so as to expend a Portkey , it has to be touched by those who want to be enthrall somewhere else – but at the end ofGoblet of Fire , Cedric ’s physical structure did n’t touch the Portkey , only Harry did . AReddituser divvy up their hypothesis about why Harry was able to bring Cedric ’s body with him through the Portkey , and it ’s , precisely , because Cedric was dead . A soul using a Portkey can bring wearable and objects with them without these meet the Portkey , so if Harry bestow Cedric ’s body with him just by touching the Portkey , it was becauseCedric had now become “ an inanimate matter ” , qualifying as an object .
How Do Portkeys Work In The Wizarding World?
Portkeys are different from Apparition
Portkeys are inanimate object that through the Portus incantation were become into these method of transportation . Wizards and witches used everyday aim that would n’t attract the aid of Muggles , so they would n’t have to worry about a Muggle accidentally travel within the Wizarding World . Once under the while , the object transport anyone who equal itto a pre - staged finish , and Portkeys can also be fascinate to enthrall the users only at a specific time . However , jaunt by Portkey is n’t a pleasant experience , and wizards and witches claim it was very uncomfortable , go to sickness , giddiness , and more .
Portkeys are similar but not the same as another means of transportation in the Wizarding World do it as “ Apparition ” . This appropriate the user to travel in a flash without traversing the space between , and as such , it was the fast way to get anywhere , but it take subordination of legerdemain , as if it was done incorrectly , it could lead to “ Splinching ” , which is when parts of the clothes or torso are left behind in the former location . Apparition does n’t ask an incantation , and instead , it ’s about skill . Harry , then , did n’t Apparatewhen he returned to Hogwarts , and it was the Portkey that transport him and Cedric ’s body back .
How This Theory Makes Harry Potter & The Goblet of Fire Even Sadder
Cedric’s death is one of the most heartbreaking moments in the saga
Harry demand Cedric ’s body with him and everyone at Hogwarts realizing Cedric was dead are some of the most tragic and disgraceful moments inHarry Potter and the Goblet of Fire , and this hypothesis only makes it even sadder . The fact that a Portkey would place a dead body as an “ object ” dehumanizes it and feels quite cruel , even more so when the someone die under horrifying and unjust circumstances , as was Cedric ’s case . Although this theory solvesHarry Potter and the Goblet of Fire ’s Portkey plot hole , it makes the third act of the flick a peck more tragical and create the aspect of Harry and Cedric ’s return even heavily to check .
