American Horror Story
All season ofAmerican Horror Storyare part of the same universe , and some of them have a mates of connection between them , and a hypothesis explain there ’s a dark one betweenMurder HouseandHotelthanks to James March ( Evan Peters ) . Each season ofAmerican Horror Storycovers a different repugnance root with either supernatural or human scoundrel ( and sometimes a combining of both ) , and with metre , it has forge a connected universe that peaked with the crossover seasonApocalypse . AHSkicked off withMurder House , which told the story of the ghost that inhabit the title haunted business firm .
After exploring the horror inside an asylum , among a coven of witches , and in a freak show , American Horror Storytook the interview to Hotel Cortezto encounter the lamia and ghosts that hold out in it . Among them was James March , the designer of the Hotel Cortez and a serial cause of death , as well as The Countess ’ ( Lady Gaga ) husband . Now , a theory indicate there ’s a sinister link betweenAHS : Murder HouseandHotelthrough Dr. Charles Montgomery ( Matt Ross ) , the original owner of the Murder House , and James March , as the latter might be responsible for a tragedy that hit the Montgomery family .
Related : Is James March A Real Person ? AHS : Hotel Inspiration Explained
What Happened To The Montgomery Baby In AHS: Murder House?
Charles Montgomery was a “ surgeon to the star ” who in 1922 build the house that would later become known as Murder House for his wife , Nora ( Lily Rabe ) . Although Charles was a illustrious surgeon , he eventually start to lose popularity , and he developed an addiction to ether as well as a “ Frankenstein Complex ” , stitching together different body parts of animals . crucify with Charles ’ post , which direct to them not being able to pay bills , Nora convinced him to perform illegal abortions in the planetary house ’s cellar . Nora ’s theme was a hit , and Charles was visited by many women , including Elizabeth Johnson / The Countess and Elizabeth Short ( Mena Suvari ) .
One 24-hour interval , one of Charles ’ patients assure her young man she had gotten an abortion with Dr. Montgomery , and in revenge , the girl ’s fellow kidnapped Charles and Nora ’s boy , Thaddeus . Charles ’ son was dismember and his remains were brought to him by the police force , and having fully lose his sanity by then , Charles bring him back to life history by sewing him back togetherand using the heart of “ one of their daughter ” . However , the resurrect Thaddeus was a monstrous and fiendish animal ( refer to as the Infantata ) who tried to suck Nora ’s stock , lead her to pour down Charles and herself . Thaddeus / The Infantata carry on living in the Murder House ’s basement , while its parent became the first ghosts to stalk the house .
Theory: James March Killed The Montgomery Baby
A theory suggeststhatAHS : Hotel ’s James March was the one creditworthy for the death of the Montgomery baby inMurder House , all thanks to the association between Charles Montgomery and The Countess . In 1926 , The Countess discovered she was significant with James ’ baby , but the maternity take place before she was turned into a vampire by the love of her liveliness , Rudolph Valentino , so she sought to end her pregnancy . However , the abortion was unsuccessful and she gave birth to a disfigured son , Bartholomew , who is trap in a perpetual state of early childhood . Elizabeth took her Word back to the hotel , where he resides in Room 33 and is tended by Iris ( Kathy Bates ) and other hotel workers , and is often visited by his female parent , who never halt lie with him .
Now , the theory excuse that James March was the angry fellow who kidnapped Thaddeus and killed the child , which is quite meet with March ’s story . As mentioned above , James March was a serial orca , and he built various private roomsand hidden hallways in Hotel Cortez so he could enshroud the grounds of his many killings , so it ’s believable that he could have been the liquidator of the Montgomery baby inMurder House , thus being the one responsible for the haunting of Murder House and all the tragedies that took piazza there , as the deaths of Charles and Nora as a result of Thaddeus ’ rebirth were the one that start it all .
concern : American Horror Story : How Every Murder House Character pass
Other Connections Between AHS: Murder House & Hotel
The Countess going to Murder House to get an abortion from Dr. Montgomery is the large connection betweenAHS : HotelandMurder House , but it is n’t the only one . Another character connect these season isBillie Dean Howard ( Sarah Paulson ) , a culture medium hired by Constance Langdon inMurder House(who told Constance about the birth of the Anti - Christ ) and later by Iris inHotel , as she wanted to put across with Liz Taylor ’s death boyfriend , Tristan Duffy . Although there ’s no denotative grounds that can confirm James March is the one responsible for the murder of the Montgomery child , the hypothesis is believable due to March ’s criminal offense and the timeline of events , and it adds another layer of darkness and horror to bothAmerican Horror Story : HotelandMurder House .
Next : American Horror Story : Every Season ’s Connection Explained
