Scream
Summary
TheScreamsaga is back thanks to the legacy sequelsScream(2022 ) andScream 6 , which have revived various hypothesis about past Ghostface grampus , especiallyStu Macher(Matthew Lillard ) . The horror genre has gain from the trend of reboots and “ requels ” , and one franchise that was successfully brought back to life through this isScream . A decennium after the saga ’s supposedly last chapter , Scream 4 , the enfranchisement was resurrect with a 5th movie , only titledScream , which contribute back the saga ’s three main characters and survivor : Sidney Prescott ( Neve Campbell ) , Gale Weathers ( Courteney Cox ) , and Dewey Riley ( David Arquette ) .
Scream2022 also introduced a new propagation of survivor , with Sam ( Melissa Barrera ) and Tara Carpenter ( Jenna Ortega ) becoming the saga ’s new Final Girls . The connections between the reboot movies and the original ones have made way for hypothesis that retcon the first four flick or try out to fill in some disruption , and many of these have included original Ghostface Stu Macher . Stu ’s destiny inScreamhas been debated for years , and some details in the reboot movies have made way for speculation on his purpose in the franchise , while others believe he had a more personal relationship with fellow Ghostface Billy Loomis . Here are some of the bestScreamtheories about Stu Macher .
Related:9 Scream Theories That Completely Change The Entire Saga
5Stu & Billy Loomis Are Half-Brothers
TheScreamsaga begin with the 1996 Woodsboro murder , led by Billy Loomis ( Skeet Ulrich ) and Stu Macher . Billy was Sidney ’s boyfriend and Stu was Billy ’s skillful ally , but they plow out to be ruthless serial killer . However , only one of them had a clean motive to go after Sidney : Billy , who memorise that Sidney ’s mother , Maureen , had an intimacy with his don , Hank , which direct to his mother abandoning them . Billy want revenge , so he and Stu came up with a plan to go on a kill spree assume the Ghostface costume , vote down Sidney , and frame her father for all the murders . Billy was push by anger and revenge , but Stu was just there for the thrill of the hunt .
A theory ( viaCBR ) gives Stu a reason to join Billy ’s architectural plan by suggesting the two friends were actually half - brothers . Scream 3revealed that Roman Bridger ( Scott Foley ) was not only Sidney ’s half - brother but also the tool master behind the original Woodsboro murders . Roman was the one who find out Maureen and Hank were having an intimacy , and showed the evidence to Billy , pushing him to intrust the murders . The theory suggest Billy did his own research after that and discovered that Hank also had an occasion with Stu ’s mom , meaning that Hank was Stu ’s founder .
The hypothesis would explain the strong and improbably patriotic bond between Stu and Billy , which emphatically went beyond friendship . This would also excuse why Stu agreed to apply his household for the concluding kill , as it would have been the ultimate revenge against his parent and their lies . The hypothesis turns Stu into a tragicScreamcharacter , one who was soak from a family thanks to Hank and Maureen ’s affair and one who was n’t avenged later on , as Billy was thanks to his mother inScream 2 .
4Stu Survived The Events Of Scream
The biggest Stu theory out there , which is also the base for many others , is the one about his selection . In the final act ofScream , Stu was weakened by Billy stab him repeatedly as part of their plan , but he still had enough strength and energy to give chase Sidney and attempt to kill her . Sidney bite his hand , hit him with a vase , and drop a TV on his head , electrocute him to destruction . However , for many viewers , this was n’t a convincing ending , and theories about Stu pull through being electrocuted at the end ofScreamgained force when the franchise was reanimate .
Many theories take that Stu somehow survive his “ death ” at the ending ofScreamand continued to work subsequent Ghostface murders in some fashion . The theories used Matthew Lillard ’s well-heeled - to - misfire cameo inScream 2to sustain the idea of Stu ’s survival , and even thoughScreamwriter Kevin Williamson affirm Stu ’s demise , the theory about Stu being alive have n’t stop . Stu was even conceive to be one of the killer inScream2022 andScream 6 , and he ’s still theorized to appear inScream 7as the large bend that retcons the former reboot pic , the same wayScream 3did with the first two picture .
3Stu Was The Fourth Killer In Scream 6
Since the firstScreammovie , there has been the belief thatthere was a third killer in everyScreammoviewith two killers , and inScream 6 ’s case , there are theories about a fourth killer . Scream 6is the first picture show in the saga to have three killer whale – Detective Bailey , Quinn Bailey , and Ethan Landry , all of them relatives ofScream2022 ’s cause of death , Richie Kirsch – but even with a third confirmed grampus , some blast and kills would have ask extra help . Enterthe fourth killer possibility inScream 6 , which suggests Sam ’s boyfriend , Danny ( Josh Segarra ) , was the undercover Ghostface and will be one of the master killers inScream 7 , but other possibility suggest the fourth Ghostface was Stu .
As cite above , it has been theorized that Stu has directly influenced other Ghostface cause of death , so if he was n’t involved inScream2022 , he might have postulate the Kirsches ’ heartache and thirst for revenge as a probability to return without being caught . Although it ’s unlikely Stu will regress inScream 7 , at this item anything can happen in the domain ofScream .
2Stu Is Tara’s Real Father
The Scream saga has two new Final Girls thanks to Sam and Tara Carpenter , with Sam having a direct inter-group communication to the original Woodsboro murders and thus theScreamsaga as she ’s Billy Loomis ’ girl . Sam has been haunted and guided by imaginativeness of Billy , and there are some theories ( viaYouTube ) that hint she is n’t the only one with a unmediated connection to one of the original Ghostfaces . A theory claim Stu is Tara ’s father , but as Tara is younger than Sam , this automatically accept the theory that Stu is alive .
The theory about Stu being Tara ’s father suggest that , after the original Woodsboro murders , Stu recovered and moved on with a fresh identity . Stu met Tara ’s female parent at some distributor point and they had Tara , but Stu abandoned Tara , Sam , and their female parent long time later after learning that Sam was Billy ’s girl . sure , there ’s a lot that plays against this peculiar theory , and there ’s no pauperism for the current Final Girls to be linked to the original Ghostface killer .
Related : Scream Family Trees : All Relatives Of Sidney , Randy , Billy , Stu & More
1Stu Is Leading A Ghostface Cult In Scream 7
Afterthe shrine shown inScream 6with objects related to past Ghostface slayer , their victim , the home where the execution were committed , and props from theStabmovies , theory about a Ghostface cult inScream 7have emerged – and who well than Stu to be the drawing card . Once more , this is a theory that take the one about Stu ’s natural selection as a fact and tries to bring him back as a secure , manipulative comportment in the saga . Scream 7is believe to mirrorScream 3 , and it ’s make love that the original plan for the third movie was to take Stu back , so those behind the theory employ this to support Stu ’s return as a craze leader .
Some theory suggest thatScream2022 ’s Richie and Amber were part of Stu ’s furor , with Richie ’s class subsequently gain out for avail to avenge Richie ’s death . Stu ’s cultus could be something he started between the issue ofScream 4andScream2022 or it could have started betweenScream 3andScream 4 , with Jill and Charlie also being part of it . A Ghostface cult inScream 7isn’t out of the land of possibility , butStu Macheras the loss leader is n’t completely believable .
